Kashmir Observer

Your Window on Kashmir

Thursday
Sep 09th
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Home

Geelani Justifies Stone-Pelting

E-mail Print PDF
User Rating: / 22
PoorBest 

Srinagar, Mar 26, KONS: Reacting to the latest controversy over the legitimacy of stone-pelting, the chairman of the Hurriyat (G), Syed Ali Shah Geelani, today said that those speaking against stone-pelting youth should first study the approach of the armed forces personnel, as there was no comparison between the gun and the stone as the latter could not take human life.
Though Geelani himself is on record for having repeatedly appealed to youth to desist from stone-pelting and other forms of violence during demonstrations, his latest remarks come in the midst of a debate in the media and the public circles about the viability and legitimacy of stone pelting, particularly after the head of the Jami’at-e-Ahl-e-Hadees, Maulana Shaukat Ahmad Shah described the act as un-Islamic.
On the day after his arrival in Srinagar after a three-month stay in New Delhi, Geelani today visited the family of Shahid Ahmad Ahangar in Rainawari who was killed in CRPF firing on protestors in Nauthatta.
Speaking at a gathering in Nauthatta where he met the family of detained pro-freedom activist, Aashiq Hussian Rangrez, Geelani said that the deployment of thousands of armed personnel needlessly in populated areas was a provocation in itself, and it was natural for youth to react with anger and pelt stones.
“To impose undeclared curfew even at prayer time and confine people indoors in tantamount to inflaming passions,” he said. “If anybody expects peace to be maintained after this, he is not using his mind.”
Asking opponents of stone pelting to first consider the behaviour of the armed personnel, Geelani said that the stone was minor thing as compared to a gun as it could not take anybody’s life.
“Under no circumstances can bullets be the answer to stones in a civilized state as this is absolute mercilessness and savagery that has no justification,” he said.
Taking a dig at pro-India leaders, Geelani said that they bore a greater responsibility than India itself for the travails of Kashmiris because they gave the stamp of legitimacy to Indian occupation, and the serious and pathetic situation in Kashmir could not reach the outside world as long as they were in power.
“They are the cause of distancing our goals,” he said, appealing to the people not to support pro-India political parties.
“Our struggle will continue so long as maintain its military occupation of Kashmir. The Indian army is not here as a peace-keeper but as an aggressor which has no justification to remain here,” he said.



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! Mixx! Free and Open Source Software News Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! Yahoo! Free Joomla PHP extensions, software, information and tutorials.
Comments
Add New Search
Gowhar  - Independent   |2010-08-12 14:43:59
The person one who see his child being killed infront of him, his home being gutted infront of him, his sister being
raped infront of him, he is least bothered about the person or perons living in glass house.

The kashmiri
people are fighting for their fundamental rights, if people of mumbai, delhi, etc can go out of their homes and
come back late in night without any threat of being killed or harrassed then why not we.

 Let me clear one doubt
from all people, kashmir was indipendent, you want to know go and read your history.

This fight will last till we
get our rights, remember.
princess  - totally justifiable   |2010-07-11 11:21:32
The unarned innocent kashmiris are left wid no other option but stone pelting..Two years back, during Amarnath land row protests
in Jammu not even a single fire was shot .On the contrary water was used as a dispersing medium for the crowd. Are all rules and
regulations only for kashmiri people?
Vivek Koul  - Why mix religion here????   |2010-07-09 22:54:23
Folks I dont understand why stone pelting is being compared to islamic/unIslamic character by Mr Geelani......first people like
Geelani desist people from stone pelting and then they themselves justify it so that religious leaders have a crack at it.....
..such a pity that Kashmiris dont have any political options.....all of you are your self witnesses of how leaders like Geelani
tarnish image of Kashmir as well as Islam........ek teer se do shikaar politics......
Zubair  - We will fight till our last breath   |2010-06-29 15:30:46
We shall remain steadfast till we achieve our goal. People throughout ages have suffered at the hands of oppreser but
only those who remained firm and convicted achieved their goal. t3RCF
yAWAR  - Stone Is The Only Weapon   |2010-06-28 01:03:11
sTONE iS tHE oNLY wEAPON FOR KASHMIRIS TO FIGHT AGANIST INDIAN TERRORISM.................
Arsh Qadiri  - be optimistic   |2009-10-29 00:13:23
Well, the lacuna with us Muslims is that we don't have a particular slogan. Our goal, our opinion & our endeavor is
scattered in every step of our life, it’s sarcastic to say but its reality. We were taught by our Prophet Muhammad
(p.b.u.h) "hold fast the rope of Allah and don't get divided" but today our each & every act
is antithetical towards the teaching of Allah & his messenger (p.b.u.h). Regarding the stone pelting it’s not
such an issue to be given hype, we are not strong in terms of arms & ammunition so it’s a mere effort from us to
challenge the oppression & tyrannization of Indian brutal forces. It’s a medium to show to the world that we don’t
keep mum for the atrocities committed by barbaric & ruthless Indian militia. There is well said that only the
wearer know were the shoe pinches. When Mr. Showkat will come across a bullet ridden body of his relative or his close
ones surely he will come to know the importance of a stone pelter or stone pelting…
sss  - dont have an option   |2009-08-30 09:59:39
well what option does the hotblooded youth of kashmir have rather then pelting stones when we are being humiliated on the daily
and are being denied basic fundamental rights should we rather become sucide bombers or should we turn to the gun we abandoned,
we dont have aleaders like mandela and gandhi to turn to , our leadership either busy makin millions or making hallow speeches,
well youth wants to get out and do something and they unfortunately dont have any other option our leaders may be impotent to act
but our concious is not dead we ll not let ourselves be humulated annd do nothin about it we have to stand for our rights and we
are doing that awe unfortunately dont have any other method of expressing ourselves other than pelting stones
dar  - citizen duties   |2009-07-29 15:11:54
The political situation in valley is such that it has become a fight of ego, all the super powers are so much interested in the
valley tht many things unheard of happen and grand coverups are also rampant, the citizen has no significant right, men of power
are unaccountable and scope for improvment of living standards is limited, security situation on citizen level is dismal as in
rest of sub continent. but harrasment is a habit and death is frequent and people are so used to it. overall the citizen is not
interested in the well being of valley and is unwilling to create a safe place. unity seems to be absent and motivation to break
the ice is lacking. There is a lack of strong brother hood sentiment and millitary culture is lacking. It is a known fact that
seriousness of situation is such that it is one of the remotest place in subcontinent leave for the millitary infrastructre
administrative financial and constiutionaland law&order agencies reforms are a urgent requirment for the decay to be reversed and
well being of citizens.
Ramu  - Keep fighting   |2009-05-29 09:34:21
All Kashmiri brothers: Justifying one crime with another and making lame excuses has been the character of kashmiris for
centuries. Its nothing new, so keep fighting, arguing and speeding towards dark ages. Which side I am taking is for you to ask not
to me, but yourselves.
Majid  - We Muslim r un-islamic   |2009-05-24 00:49:10
On the one side we talk about peaceful marches and then by throwing stones we are changing our peaceful marches into violent ones.
What Showket sb. meant is that Don\'t show dual character which is un-islamic and we r showing it that means we Muslim are
un-islamic and in this way stone pelting is un-islamic.If u are pelting stones then don\'t hesitate to tell in media that we
do it because aazadi is our right and to fight for getting our rights is jehad and doing jehad is farz on every healthy
muslim.....
junaid  - ahlihadees kaekgi   |2009-05-08 15:15:45
this is the perfect example of ahle hadees kaekgi ..if throwing stones at the occupying army men who weild guns and shoot
innocent people, is unislamic then waging jihad against the forced indian occupation using guns should be more unislamic by his
standards and stones cant possibly kill someone .. i would like to ask this ahle hadees kaek maulvi what suggestion s does he have
for militants fighting indian army .. i think sticks and ropes ...
Noor Ul Mushtaq  - Why Un Islamic   |2009-03-30 11:25:08
If stone pelting is Un-Islamic then let all followers of Jamiat Ahle Hadith chief resign from Banking sector as that is totally
unislamic & let them abstain from Life Insurance and General Provident Fund.
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Title:
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

 

News in Pictures

Geelani waving to mediamen outside his residence before his arrest Geelani waving to mediamen outside his residence before his arrest Syed Ali Geelani being arrested Advisor to Chief Minister visited curfew bound Eidgah Wednesday Sheikh family members at the mazar of late Shiekh Mohamad Abdullah Women protesters hurling potatoes at the police & CRPF men at Chattabal-CNS A scene of a clash in old city on Wednesday- Altaf Qadri A view of curfew bound Srinagar- AP Mother of Showkat Ahmad Malik kissing his son good bye:Pix Burhan Kinu Paramilitary soldiers arrive at the site of a protest in Srinagar-Mukhtar Khan
Kashmir Observer on Facebook

Recent Comments

Most Voted

Translate

Add to Google
We have 352 guests online

KO Poll

What exactly are the protesting youth in Kashmir demanding?